DI GIUSEPPE SALVATORE ROCCO PROCOPIO
ABSTRACT – With the judgment under review, the Council of State – Third
Section – offers the occasion for a reflection on the ascending trajectory of
the principle of result, now enshrined in Article 1 of Legislative Decree No.
36/2023 as a Leitmotiv of the codified architecture of public contracts. The
case, concerning the exclusion of a bid lacking the supply of soda lime
indispensable to the functioning of anaesthesia equipment, provides the
occasion to examine the tension between formal and substantive legality,
between procedural rigour and the teleology of administrative action. The
Panel, qualifying the contract as an obligation of result, elevates concrete
functionality to the yardstick for assessing technical equivalence, redrawing
the boundaries between review of legitimacy and administrative merit. The
study assesses the true innovative import of this principle, with regard to
the interpretation of the lex specialis, technical discretion, and the operation,
in the case at hand, of the most liquid reason. A balanced reading is reached:
the principle of result, while rising to the status of a lodestar of public action,
does not yet appear to attain the rank of an autonomous standard of
judgment, resolving itself more often into an argumentative buttress for
solutions already attainable through traditional hermeneutic tools.
KEYWORDS – Principle of result – substantive legality – public contracts –
technical equivalence – technical discretion – judicial review.