| RIVISTA SEMESTRALE - ISSN 2421-0730 - ANNO XII - NUMERO 1 - GIUGNO 2026

La comprensione di intercettazioni poco intellegibili: non sempre è bene credere alle proprie orecchie

DI MASSIMO GRASSI, MARIA GRAZIA VACCARO, GIUSEPPE SARTORI

ABSTRACT – Audio recordings – such as environmental wiretaps – are often

used as evidence to support accusatory or defensive arguments.

Normally, these recordings are entrusted to a technical consultant or

expert who has the task of transcribing the content. Subsequently, the

debate takes place starting from and based on the transcribed text. This

passage hides difficulties which can become a serious problem if the

recordings contain incomprehensible material. We will propose a method

to quantify how intelligible the content of a given recording is.

Furthermore, we will propose a method for producing a transcription that

is maximally shareable. The contents and methods presented here concern

in particular the transcription of degraded or unintelligible audio, either

because it was recorded with poor quality equipment or techniques, or

because the recording conditions were not optimal. The text is divided

into three parts. In the first we will highlight how understanding the

content of unintelligible recordings is an extremely influential process. In

the second, we will propose the method for the numerical estimation of

intelligibility and the one for the reconstruction of a transcription that can

be maximally shared. In the third, both methods will be applied to a

recently debated murder case.

KEYWORDS – wiretapping – registration – intelligible – support accusatory – support defensive.

SCARICA IL CONTRIBUTO INTEGRALE